This page is general information, not legal advice. US rule. It describes the test the IRS applies to decide whether a payer owes federal employment taxes on payments to a worker. Other agencies use other tests, and a result under this one does not carry over to them.
What the test is
The IRS Publication 15-A sorts workers into four groups: independent contractors, common-law employees, statutory employees and statutory nonemployees. For most freelance accountants the live question is the first two.
The publication gives the general rule. A business that controls only the result of the work, and not the means and methods of reaching it, is dealing with an independent contractor. Anyone whose services the payer controls, in what is done and how it is done, is generally a common-law employee. The substance of the relationship governs, not the label (IRS Publication 15-A).
The IRS also says that the right to control matters, not only control that is exercised. In its guidance for independent contractors, an employer's legal right to control the details of how services are performed means the worker is not an independent contractor, even if the worker has freedom of action in practice (IRS, Independent Contractor Defined).
The three categories of evidence
The IRS asks you to look at the whole relationship through three categories. The IRS states that no one factor stands alone in making the determination.
Behavioural control
The question the IRS poses is whether the payer controls, or has the right to control, what the worker does and how the worker does the job. Publication 15-A identifies instructions the payer gives and training the payer provides as evidence in this category.
For an accountant, typical facts include:
- whether the payer tells you when, where and in what order to do the work, or only what the finished product must contain;
- whether the payer requires you to follow its internal methods beyond what a professional standard or a client deliverable requires;
- whether the payer trains you in how to do the work, as opposed to explaining what the deliverable is.
Financial control
The IRS asks whether the business side of the worker's job is controlled by the payer. Publication 15-A lists these kinds of facts:
- Unreimbursed expenses. Whether the worker bears the costs of doing the work.
- Investment. Whether the worker has invested in equipment, software or training.
- Availability to the market. Whether the worker offers services to other payers.
- How the worker is paid. The method of payment, such as a fee for a deliverable or a regular amount for time.
- Profit or loss. Whether the worker can make a profit or suffer a loss from the work.
Type of relationship
The third category asks about written contracts and employee-type benefits (the IRS gives pension plans, insurance and vacation pay as examples). It also asks whether the relationship is expected to continue and whether the services are a key aspect of the payer's regular business.
A written contract is evidence of the parties' intent and terms. It does not override the other facts.
Where "licensed professional" fits
The IRS's page on independent contractors says that professionals such as doctors, lawyers, accountants and contractors who offer services to the general public are generally independent contractors, and adds that the facts of each case determine the classification. Read that as a starting observation about how professionals commonly work, not as an answer for any particular arrangement. A licence is not one of the three categories, and the DOL's own guidance, in a different test, says being licensed by a state or local government does not determine status.
Statutory employees and statutory nonemployees
Publication 15-A describes two groups defined by statute that sit outside the three-category analysis:
- Statutory employees. Certain workers who would otherwise be independent contractors are treated as employees for some employment tax purposes. The publication names four occupational groups. Social security and Medicare taxes apply when specific conditions are met, and no federal income tax withholding applies.
- Statutory nonemployees. Direct sellers, licensed real estate agents and certain companion sitters are treated as self-employed when specific conditions are met.
Accounting is not named in either list. Read the publication's definitions if you do work that touches one of those groups.
What follows from the answer
If the worker is an independent contractor, the worker is self-employed, and the IRS says the worker's income from the work is subject to self-employment tax.
If the worker is a common-law employee, the IRS says the worker's pay is generally reported on Form W-2 and may be subject to FICA and income tax withholding.
If the payer treated a worker as a contractor and the IRS finds otherwise, the payer can owe employment taxes. Publication 15-A describes a relief provision, which the IRS calls Section 530 relief (IRS, Independent Contractor (Self-Employed) or Employee?). A payer that had a reasonable basis for not treating a worker as an employee may be relieved of employment taxes, if it filed the required information returns consistently and did not treat workers in substantially similar positions as employees for periods after 1977. If the payer lacks a reasonable basis, the relief does not apply. The IRS adds that relief does not determine a worker to be an independent contractor. See misclassification: risks for workers and for businesses.
How to ask the IRS to decide
Form SS-8 asks the IRS to determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor for federal employment tax and income tax withholding purposes. Either the business or the worker may file it. The IRS reviews the facts and makes the official determination, and its page on independent contractors says that this can take at least six months. Form SS-8 is an IRS form with its own instructions: read the current form and instructions on the IRS page before filing.
The IRS also describes the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program, which lets a payer that has treated workers as nonemployees reclassify them as employees for future periods with partial relief from federal employment taxes, by filing Form 8952 (IRS, Voluntary Classification Settlement Program). The IRS asks for the application at least 120 days before the date the payer wants to start treating the workers as employees.
How to use this in practice
- List each client engagement separately. The test is applied to each relationship, not to your practice as a whole.
- For each engagement, write down the facts under the three categories, in your own words, before you look at the contract.
- Compare the facts with the contract. Where they differ, the facts are what the IRS asks about.
- Note facts you can change, such as who supplies tools or whether you can decline work, and facts you cannot change, such as the nature of the engagement.
- If a client's treatment of you matters to a tax position you have taken, ask a tax professional or an employment lawyer, or consider Form SS-8.
The self-check turns this into a worksheet.
Frequently asked questions
Is this the same test the Department of Labor uses?
No. The DOL applies an economic reality analysis under the Fair Labor Standards Act. See where the DOL rule stands.
Does a Form 1099 decide the answer?
No. The IRS says that if an employer-employee relationship exists, "regardless of what the relationship is called", the worker is not an independent contractor.
Does one client for most of a year make me an employee?
The IRS lists permanence of the relationship among the facts under type of relationship, and no one factor stands alone, so duration is one fact to weigh and not a cut-off.
Who can file Form SS-8?
Either the business or the worker.
Sources
- IRS, Independent Contractor (Self-Employed) or Employee? (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- IRS, Independent Contractor Defined (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- IRS, Publication 15-A (2026), Employer's Supplemental Tax Guide (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- IRS, About Form SS-8 (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- IRS, Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (retrieved 2026-11-20)