Section 7216 vs section 6713 vs Circular 230

How the criminal rule in 26 USC 7216, the civil penalty in 6713 and Circular 230 section 10.51(a)(15) differ, with figures taken from the primary text.

US rule · Updated November 20, 2026

US rule. Three separate layers can apply when a tax professional misuses return information: a criminal statute (section 7216), a civil penalty (section 6713) and a professional-conduct rule for practitioners (Circular 230). They use similar words and different tests. This page sets them side by side so you know which one is which. General information, not legal advice.

Side by side

Section 7216 Section 6713 Circular 230, 31 CFR 10.51(a)(15)
Type Criminal (misdemeanor) Civil penalty Professional discipline
Who Preparers and people providing services connected with preparing returns The same group Practitioners, as Circular 230 defines them
Conduct Knowingly or recklessly disclosing or using information furnished for a return, other than to prepare the return Disclosing or using that information Willfully disclosing or otherwise using a return or return information in a manner the Code does not authorize, or contrary to a court or administrative law judge order
Outcome Fine, up to one year in prison, or both, plus costs Money penalty per disclosure or use, with an annual cap Conduct for which a practitioner may be sanctioned under section 10.50

Section 7216: the criminal rule

Section 7216(a) covers a person in the business of preparing federal returns, or providing services in connection with them, and anyone who prepares such a return for compensation. It applies where that person knowingly or recklessly discloses information furnished for the return, or uses it for any purpose other than preparing or helping to prepare it. The fine is up to $1,000, imprisonment is up to one year, or both, with prosecution costs. Where section 6713(b) applies, the fine can be up to $100,000 (26 USC 7216(a)).

The exceptions in 7216(b) are the legal-obligation exceptions (disclosure under another Code provision or a court order), use for the same person's state and local returns, and whatever the Treasury regulations permit, which must include quality and peer reviews.

Section 6713: the civil penalty

Section 6713 reaches the same group for the same conduct: disclosing information furnished for a return, or using it for something other than preparing or helping to prepare the return. The penalty is $250 for each disclosure or use, with a cap of $10,000 for a calendar year. If the disclosure or use is connected with a crime involving misuse of another person's identity as defined in section 6103(b)(6), the penalty is $1,000 for each violation, capped at $50,000 for a calendar year. The two caps are tracked separately. The enhanced rule applies to disclosures and uses on or after July 1, 2019 (26 USC 6713).

The exceptions in section 7216(b) apply to section 6713 too, so a disclosure the regulations permit is outside both. The deficiency procedures of chapter 63 subchapter B do not apply to assessing or collecting the penalty.

Circular 230: the practitioner rule

Circular 230 is Part 10 of Title 31 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Section 10.51 lists conduct that counts as disreputable and for which a practitioner may be sanctioned under section 10.50. Paragraph (a)(15) lists willfully disclosing or using a tax return or return information in a manner not authorized by the Internal Revenue Code, or contrary to a court or administrative law judge order (31 CFR 10.51(a)(15)).

Three points follow from the text.

  • It binds practitioners as Circular 230 defines them (31 CFR 10.3), not every preparer. Read the definition in the Circular itself before assuming you are inside or outside.
  • It uses the word "willfully". The criminal rule uses "knowingly or recklessly". The words differ and so can the outcome.
  • The paragraph turns on what the Code authorizes. It does not mention section 7216 by number, so whether a given disclosure is authorized is answered by the Code itself, including section 7216 and its regulations.

Other layers

  • AICPA Code of Professional Conduct has a section on confidential client information (section 1.700). It binds AICPA members and sits on top of the rules above. Read the Code's own text for what it requires.
  • State boards of accountancy and state law may add rules on confidentiality and breach notification. Check your state board for its wording.
  • Contracts with firms and clients often restate the rules in stricter terms. Follow the stricter one.
  • Outside the United States, check your own regulator.

Frequently asked questions

If I follow section 7216, am I automatically fine under the others?

No. Each layer has its own test, who it binds and who enforces it. A disclosure the regulations permit is outside sections 7216 and 6713, but a contract or state rule may still bar it.

Can I be liable under both 7216 and 6713 for the same act?

The statutes are separate, and the text of each describes the same conduct. Which consequences follow in a given case is a question for counsel.

Does Circular 230 apply to me if I am not a CPA?

It depends on whether you are a practitioner as the Circular defines the term. The definition lists attorneys, CPAs, enrolled agents, enrolled actuaries, enrolled retirement plan agents and registered tax return preparers who may practice before the IRS (31 CFR 10.2(a)(5) and 10.3). An enrolled agent is a practitioner without being a CPA; a bookkeeper with none of those statuses is not.

What to do

  1. Treat the strictest of the layers that applies to you as your working rule.
  2. Keep return information in the firm's workspace, away from personal storage, email and unapproved software.
  3. Write down the permitted-disclosure paragraph or the consent you are relying on whenever you share return information.
  4. If in doubt, ask the firm's responsible CPA or counsel before sharing.

Sources

Last verified November 20, 2026. Sources checked by the editorial team; not yet reviewed by a named professional. General information, not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Related pages

Terms used on this page

Section 7216

Join the CORAA CPA network waitlist

CORAA prepares audit files for US CPA firms. Network members are independent contractors who clear what the software flags, with evidence and a note, paid per file under a contractor agreement.

  • Files are offered to you; you accept or decline
  • No exclusivity: you can work for others
  • The firm reviews and signs; CORAA never does

* required