What cleanup is
Country-neutral practice, with US references where noted. A bookkeeping cleanup brings a client's books to the point where reports can be trusted: transactions are recorded in the right period and the right accounts, bank and card accounts agree to external statements, and open items are listed instead of buried. Firms request it when books have fallen behind, a new client arrives with messy records, or a bookkeeper has left.
Cleanup is not an audit and it is not a tax return. It supports whatever comes next: financial statements, a compilation or review, a tax filing, or a lender's request. Say at the start what comes next, because the standard of care and the documentation depend on it.
Why records matter
In the US, the IRS says good records help a business monitor its progress, prepare financial statements, identify sources of income, track deductible expenses and the basis of property, prepare tax returns, and support items reported on those returns. The IRS also says any system that clearly shows income and expenses will do, and that records must be kept as long as needed to prove the income or deductions on a return (IRS, Recordkeeping). That is the reason cleanup is worth doing carefully: the books are the support.
The order of work
A cleanup runs best in a fixed order, because later steps depend on earlier ones.
- Scope and period. Which entity, which dates, which accounts, what output.
- Collect source documents. Bank and card statements for every account, loan statements, payroll reports, sales reports, prior-year statements, tax filings if relevant.
- Take a copy of the books as received. Never clean in the only copy. Save the starting trial balance. Everything you change should be traceable to that starting point.
- Reconcile cash. Reconcile every bank and credit card account to the statement for each month. Cash is the anchor for everything else.
- Review the chart of accounts. Merge duplicates, rename unclear accounts, and look for accounts with unusual balances: negative assets, credit-balance expenses, large "ask my accountant" or suspense balances.
- Clear uncategorized items. Code them from evidence. When the evidence is missing, list the item for the client and leave it in a clearly named holding account.
- Check the sub-ledgers. Receivables and payables listings should agree to the control accounts. Old unapplied payments and credits are a common source of errors.
- Check loans, assets and equity. Loan balances agree to lender statements; asset additions are capitalised or expensed consistently; owner draws and contributions are not mixed with expenses.
- Check for cut-off. Transactions near period ends belong in the right period.
- Review the result. Compare to prior periods and to expectations. A line that moved a lot needs an explanation.
- Write the summary. What you did, what you changed, what remains open.
Document as you go
The firm will want to see what changed and why. For each adjustment keep:
- the account and amount before and after,
- the source document that supports the change,
- the date and your initials,
- a one-line reason.
A change log that lists journal entries with their support lets a reviewer check a hundred changes quickly. A set of entries labelled "adjustment" does not.
If the client's own records are incomplete, say so in the log and do not guess. For the SSARS, an accountant who becomes aware that information provided by management is incomplete, inaccurate or otherwise unsatisfactory brings that to management's attention and requests additional or corrected information (AR-C 80.14).
When cleanup becomes something else
If the firm will prepare financial statements from the cleaned books, it will do so under a defined engagement. Two of those under the AICPA's SSARS matter for scope:
- Preparation of financial statements (AR-C 70). A nonattest service. It does not require the accountant to determine independence and does not require verifying the accuracy or completeness of management's information (AR-C 70.03 and .04). Each page of the statements carries a statement that no assurance is provided; if that cannot be done, the accountant issues a disclaimer, performs a compilation, or withdraws (AR-C 70.14).
- Compilation (AR-C 80). Not an assurance engagement and likewise carries no requirement to test the accuracy of management's information (AR-C 80.02). It requires reading the statements and considering whether they appear appropriate in form and free from obvious material misstatements (AR-C 80.13).
Cleanup done well makes either engagement easier. But do not describe your cleanup as an engagement under those standards. The engagement belongs to the firm and the firm's own letter defines it.
What you do not do
- Make up a figure to force a balance.
- Delete a transaction because you cannot find support. Reverse it with a note, or leave it flagged.
- Change prior periods that have been filed or reported without telling the manager first.
- Contact the client's bank or customers unless the firm has asked you to.
- Give tax advice, unless that is your engagement and you are qualified.
Common findings
- Uncleared items in a bank account that are years old.
- Personal expenses paid from the business account and recorded as business costs.
- Loan payments recorded fully as expense, with no principal reduction.
- Sales tax or payroll liabilities that do not agree to filings.
- Duplicate invoices or bills.
- Opening balances that differ from the prior period's closing balances.
Illustrative example, invented figures: the books show a bank balance of 18,400 at month-end. The statement shows 19,150. Two checks totalling 750 (500 + 250) are outstanding. 19,150 minus 750 equals 18,400, so the account reconciles. The cleanup step is to check that the two checks really are outstanding and not stale.
Handoff
Finish with a short note to the firm: the scope covered, the starting and ending trial balance, the list of adjustments, the open items by owner, and anything that looked unusual. Do not leave a conclusion about the client's affairs in a chat message; put it where the firm's file is.
FAQ
Is cleanup billable as bookkeeping or accounting?
That depends on the agreement. Say in writing what is in scope and how it is measured.
How far back should I go?
As far as the scope says. If opening balances look wrong, tell the manager and ask before widening the work.
What if the client's records are missing?
List what is missing and by whom it was requested. Do not reconstruct it by estimate unless the firm asks for an estimate and labels it.
Do I need to keep records of my own work?
Yes. Keep what the firm requires, in the place it requires, for as long as the agreement says. The IRS also says to keep your own business records as long as needed to prove income or deductions on a return.
Sources
- IRS, Recordkeeping: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/recordkeeping
- AICPA, AR-C Section 70, Preparation of Financial Statements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 80, Compilation Engagements (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective