Two engagements, one family
US rule. The AICPA's Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services (SSARS) cover three engagements that do not involve an audit: preparation of financial statements (AR-C 70), compilation (AR-C 80) and review (AR-C 90). This page covers the first two. They are different engagements with different obligations, so the first job on any file is to identify which one the firm has accepted.
This is general information on the standard. The firm's engagement letter and the current text of the standard govern, and the firm decides what it issues.
Preparation of financial statements (AR-C 70)
AR-C 70 applies when an accountant in public practice is engaged to prepare financial statements and is not engaged to audit, review or compile them (AR-C 70.01). Four features define it.
- It is a nonattest service and does not require a determination about whether the accountant is independent of the entity (AR-C 70.03).
- It does not require the accountant to test the accuracy or completeness of the information management provides, or to gather evidence for an opinion or conclusion (AR-C 70.04).
- The accountant prepares the statements using the records, documents, explanations and other information provided by management (AR-C 70.13).
- Each page of the statements carries a statement that "no assurance is provided". If that cannot be done, the accountant issues a disclaimer that makes clear no assurance is provided, performs a compilation, or withdraws from the engagement (AR-C 70.14).
The terms of the engagement are agreed with management and documented in an engagement letter or other written agreement that both sides sign (AR-C 70.10 and .11). Documentation includes at minimum that agreement and a copy of the statements the accountant prepared (AR-C 70.22).
Compilation (AR-C 80)
A compilation is not an assurance engagement. It does not require the accountant to test the accuracy or completeness of management's information or gather evidence for an opinion or conclusion (AR-C 80.02). Its objective is to apply accounting and financial reporting expertise to help management present financial statements, without undertaking to obtain or provide any assurance that no material modifications are needed (AR-C 80.04).
Key requirements for file work:
- Independence determination. The accountant must determine whether they are independent of the entity (AR-C 80.07). If not independent, the report says so in a final paragraph (AR-C 80.22).
- Management's acknowledgement. As a condition of acceptance, management acknowledges responsibility for preparation and fair presentation and for including all appropriate disclosures, and agrees that the compilation report goes in any document containing the statements that indicates the accountant performed a compilation, unless a different understanding is reached (AR-C 80.08).
- Engagement letter. The terms are agreed and documented, signed by both sides, covering objectives, management's responsibilities, the accountant's responsibilities, the limitations of the engagement, the framework, and the expected form of the report (AR-C 80.10 and .11).
- Understanding. The accountant obtains an understanding of the applicable financial reporting framework and the significant accounting policies intended to be used (AR-C 80.12).
- Procedures. The accountant reads the statements, in light of that understanding, and considers whether they appear appropriate in form and free from obvious material misstatements (AR-C 80.13).
- Unsatisfactory information. If records, explanations or judgments from management are incomplete, inaccurate or otherwise unsatisfactory, the accountant brings that to management's attention and requests additional or corrected information (AR-C 80.14).
- Revisions. If the statements do not adequately describe the framework, need revision, or are otherwise misleading, the accountant proposes revisions to management (AR-C 80.15).
- Withdrawal. The accountant withdraws if management fails to provide requested information so the work cannot be completed, or if management does not make proposed revisions and the accountant decides not to disclose the departures in the report (AR-C 80.16).
- Report. The report is in writing and has specified elements, including a statement that management is responsible for the statements, a statement that the accountant did not audit or review the statements and was not required to perform procedures on the accuracy or completeness of the information, and gives no assurance, the firm's signature, the city and state where the accountant practices, and a date that is when the required procedures were completed (AR-C 80.17).
Minimum documentation for a compilation is the engagement letter or other written agreement, a copy of the statements and a copy of the report, in sufficient detail to provide a clear understanding of the work performed (AR-C 80.40).
Preparation versus compilation
| Point | Preparation (AR-C 70) | Compilation (AR-C 80) |
|---|---|---|
| Attest or nonattest | Nonattest | Not assurance, but a report is issued |
| Independence | No determination required | Determination required; report states lack of independence |
| Report | No compilation report; no-assurance statement on each page, or a disclaimer | Compilation report with required elements |
| Testing management's data | Not required | Not required |
| Minimum documentation | Agreement and statements | Agreement, statements and report |
Where a review differs
A review adds limited assurance. The accountant must be independent, performs primarily analytical procedures and inquiries, and documents the procedures and conclusions so another accountant can follow them (AR-C 90.03, .04, .10 and .137). The review file page in this section covers that work.
What a contributor prepares
On these engagements, freelance work is usually one or more of the following:
- Drafting the statements from the trial balance in the firm's template.
- Building the tie-out between the trial balance, the statements and the notes.
- Drafting the notes from the firm's disclosure checklist.
- Producing supporting schedules for items the firm asks about.
- Checking the statements for obvious problems: figures that do not agree, labels that do not match, missing periods, inconsistent signs.
- Assembling the file: engagement letter, statements, report draft, open items.
The decisions that belong to the firm are acceptance of the engagement, the independence determination, which form of report to issue, any modification, and signing.
Common problems in these files
- No signed engagement letter in the file.
- Statements that do not identify the framework used.
- Pages missing the "no assurance" statement on a preparation engagement.
- A compilation report that does not reflect a lack of independence, or a disclosure of reasons that is incomplete. If the accountant discloses reasons for impaired independence, the standard requires all reasons to be included (AR-C 80.23).
- Statements that omit substantially all disclosures where doing so could mislead users. The accountant should not issue a compilation report in that case if, in professional judgment, the statements would be misleading (AR-C 80.26).
- A report that states the statements are not in conformity with the framework. The standard says not to modify a compilation report to say that (AR-C 80.33).
If you see one of these, tell the manager. Do not decide the answer yourself.
Illustrative file check
Invented figures. The statements show total assets of 410,000. The balance sheet lists current assets of 160,000 and non-current assets of 250,000. 160,000 + 250,000 = 410,000, so the statement foots. Total liabilities of 190,000 plus equity of 220,000 also equal 410,000. The tie-out note records that the statement foots, which agrees to the trial balance, and that the notes agree to the statements.
FAQ
Can the same accountant prepare and compile?
The standard addresses what happens when an accountant prepares statements and cannot add the no-assurance statement to each page: the accountant issues a disclaimer, performs a compilation, or withdraws (AR-C 70.14). The firm decides.
Does a compilation require me to check the client's numbers?
No. The accountant is not required to test accuracy or completeness (AR-C 80.02). But the accountant must read the statements, and must raise matters that appear unsatisfactory (AR-C 80.13 and .14).
What does my file need to show?
At minimum, what the standard lists, plus whatever the firm's methodology adds. Keep drafts of the statements and open items that explain what changed.
Is there a standard for state or other frameworks?
The AR-C sections refer to an applicable financial reporting framework, which may be GAAP or a special purpose framework. The engagement letter identifies it.
Sources
- AICPA, AR-C Section 80, Compilation Engagements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 70, Preparation of Financial Statements (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 90, Review of Financial Statements (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective