What tie-out is
US rule for the documentation points; country-neutral as practice. Tie-out is the check that numbers agree where they should: statements to the trial balance, notes to the statements, schedules to the ledger, ledger to outside evidence. It finds footing errors, transposed figures, stale comparatives and notes that disagree with the face of the statements. It is clerical in method and important in effect, because a statement that does not agree to its own support is not ready to go anywhere.
Tie-out is not a substitute for audit or review procedures. It shows consistency. Whether the underlying figures are right is a different question. In a review under the SSARS, evidence that the statements agree or reconcile with the accounting records is a specific requirement (AR-C 90.41), so a clean tie-out is part of that evidence.
Tick marks and references
A tie-out needs a legend. Each tick mark has one meaning, and the legend sits on the workpaper or in a referenced index. Common marks include: agreed to the prior-year statements, agreed to the trial balance, agreed to the schedule, footed, cross-footed, agreed to the third-party document. Do not invent a mark and leave it unexplained.
For every figure that is ticked, the reviewer should be able to find the item you compared to. AU-C 230 asks for the identifying characteristics of the specific items tested (AU-C 230.09a) and gives examples, such as recording the dates and unique numbers of documents selected for a test (AU-C 230.A14). On a tie-out, that means references to the page, line or cell, not just a tick.
The standard sequence
- Freeze the versions. Record the date and version of the trial balance and the draft statements you are tying out. If either changes, the tie-out must be repeated for the changed items.
- Statements to trial balance. Every line on the face agrees to a trial balance grouping. Foot each column. Cross-foot where totals appear across.
- Comparatives. Prior-year columns agree to the prior-year issued statements or final file.
- Notes to statements. Every figure in a note agrees to the face of the statements or to a schedule, and every note on the face refers to a note that exists.
- Schedules to ledger. Each supporting schedule agrees to the ledger balance it supports.
- Cross-statement checks. Net income in the income statement agrees to the equity roll-forward; ending cash in the cash flow statement agrees to the balance sheet; the equity roll-forward agrees.
- Text. Entity name, period, dates, framework, accounting policy descriptions and references agree throughout.
- Subsequent changes. When adjustments are posted, re-tie the affected lines. Record that you did.
A worked example
Illustrative example, invented figures. A trial balance shows accounts payable of 212,400. The supporting listing has three vendor balances: 120,900, 64,300 and 26,700.
- Foot the listing: 120,900 + 64,300 = 185,200; 185,200 + 26,700 = 211,900.
- Compare to the ledger: 212,400 − 211,900 = 500.
The schedule does not agree by 500. The tie-out records the difference, not a tick. The follow-up could be a missing item, a credit memo, or a footing error in the original listing. Until the difference is explained, the line is open and the note to the reviewer says so, with the amount and what you have checked.
When the figures agree but something is still wrong
Agreement shows consistency, not truth. Watch for:
- A schedule built from the ledger, so it agrees by construction.
- A comparative that agrees to last year's draft instead of the issued version.
- A note that agrees numerically but describes the wrong period.
- Round figures that agree because someone typed the total to match.
- A difference "plugged" into another line to make it tie.
If you suspect any of these, record it and tell the reviewer. For audits, the auditor's skepticism requirement applies to the engagement (AU-C 200.17), and a contributor should surface an oddity rather than work around it.
Reviewing a workpaper
When your task is to review another person's workpaper, use the AU-C 230 test: could an experienced auditor with no previous connection to the audit understand the procedures, results, evidence and significant matters (AU-C 230.08)? A workable check, in order:
- Header. Entity, period, area, workpaper reference, preparer and date.
- Purpose. Does it say what the workpaper is for and which assertion or risk it addresses?
- Source. Is the starting balance referenced to the trial balance or another controlled source?
- Procedure. Does it state what was done, to which items, in enough detail to repeat?
- Evidence. Is every conclusion referenced to evidence in the file?
- Results. Are exceptions and differences listed, with how each was resolved?
- Conclusion. Does it say what the evidence supports, and does that follow from the work?
- Sign-off. Who performed the work and when; who reviewed it and when (AU-C 230.09b and c).
- Cross-references. Do links to other workpapers work and point to the right place?
- Consistency. Do figures agree to other workpapers and to the draft statements?
Write notes in the form the review notes page describes: where, what, what is needed, priority.
Who reviews and what review means
The engagement partner is responsible for direction, supervision and review of the team's work (AU-C 220.29) and reviews documentation of significant matters and judgments (AU-C 220.31). Your review of another person's workpaper is a step in that structure, not a replacement for the partner's review. The standard also says the requirement to document who reviewed work does not imply that each working paper must contain evidence of review. It means documenting what work was reviewed, by whom, and when (AU-C 230.A15). Follow the firm's sign-off method and record your review in it.
Version control
Remote work multiplies copies. Keep one working copy in the firm's workspace. Name versions with dates. Do not email drafts. Before tie-out, make sure you have the latest version; after, note which version you tied. If the firm uses locks or check-out, use them.
FAQ
How much should I tick?
Everything you rely on. If a figure is not ticked, the reviewer will assume it was not checked.
Should I tie out my own work?
You can, but someone else should check it. A second set of eyes catches what the author's eyes skip.
What if the draft statements keep changing?
Ask the manager for a freeze date for the draft, and re-tie only changed lines after that, recording what changed.
Can I correct a figure I find wrong?
Report it. Whether and how to correct it is for the firm. Where you are told to correct it, record the before and after in the file.
Sources
- AICPA, AU-C Section 230, Audit Documentation (AU-C sections, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective
- AICPA, AU-C Section 220, Quality Management for an Engagement (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 90, Review of Financial Statements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective