Why review notes matter
US rule for audits; country-neutral as practice. A review note is part of the audit record. It shows that a reviewer looked at work, what they asked, and how the question was resolved. AU-C 230 says documentation must let an experienced auditor with no previous connection to the audit understand the procedures, the results and evidence, and significant findings, conclusions and judgments (AU-C 230.08). It must also record who reviewed the work and the date and extent of the review (AU-C 230.09). A note that says "see me" or "fix" and a reply that says "done" meet neither test.
The same applies to review engagements under the SSARS: review documentation must let an experienced accountant with no previous connection to the review understand the procedures, evidence, significant matters and conclusions (AR-C 90.137).
This page covers both sides: writing a note as a reviewer, and answering one as the person who prepared the work. General information; the firm's own methodology governs format.
What a good note contains
A usable note answers five questions without a phone call.
- Where: the workpaper reference, the cell, the line, the tick mark. "Page 14" is not enough if the page has twenty lines.
- What: the specific observation. "Total of 212,400 on the lead schedule does not agree to the 211,900 on the supporting list" rather than "check totals".
- Why it matters: the assertion, risk or requirement at stake, if it is not obvious.
- What is needed: a correction, a reference to evidence, an explanation, or a procedure.
- Priority: blocks the file, must clear before release, or housekeeping.
Illustrative example (invented figures): "WP B-3, accounts payable listing: listing total 211,900 vs trial balance 212,400, a 500 difference. Explain or correct. Blocks tie-out of the balance sheet." That note says where, what, what is needed and priority in one sentence.
Writing as the reviewer
- One issue per note. Combined notes get half-cleared.
- Ask for evidence, not reassurance. "Agree to the signed contract and reference it" is checkable. "Make sure this is right" is not.
- Distinguish a question from an instruction. "Why is this accrued in March?" asks for an explanation. "Reverse the accrual" directs a change. Do not blur them.
- Record the disposition. When a note is cleared, record who cleared it and when. This feeds the requirement to document who reviewed the work and when (AU-C 230.09c).
- Mark significant matters. Under AU-C 220 the engagement partner reviews documentation relating to significant matters and significant judgments (AU-C 220.31). If a note is about a significant judgment, flag it so it reaches that review.
Answering as the preparer
Reply in the same place as the note. A good reply has three parts: what you did, what you found, and a reference.
- Did: "Agreed listing to the trial balance and re-footed."
- Found: "Difference of 500 was a credit memo posted on 2 January and included in the listing in error."
- Reference: "Credit memo CM-114 attached at B-3.1. Listing corrected; new total 212,400."
Then change the workpaper, not only the note. A note cleared in the margin while the schedule still shows the old figure leaves the file inconsistent. If the answer is that no change is needed, say why, with a reference.
Do not clear a note you disagree with by silence. Say so, give your reasoning and the evidence, and let the reviewer decide. Where your reasoning conflicts with the reviewer's, the reviewer's call stands for the file, and the disagreement should be visible in the record.
Inconsistencies
If new information contradicts a conclusion on a significant matter, the standard asks the auditor to document how the inconsistency was addressed (AU-C 230.12). It does not require keeping documents that are incorrect or superseded (AU-C 230.A17). In notes, this means a reply such as "earlier version of the schedule showed X; superseded by Y because Z" is better than quietly replacing X.
Dates, names and sign-off
Every note and reply carries a name or initials and a date, consistent with the firm's convention. For audits, the dates matter beyond tidiness: the documentation completion date is no later than 60 days after the report release date (AU-C 230.16), and changes after that date must be documented with reasons, who made them, and when (AU-C 230.18). Do not add or alter notes in a file the firm has marked complete.
Tone
Notes are read later by people who were not there. Keep them neutral, specific, and about the work, not the person. "Support for the 4,000 receipt is not attached" is a note. "Sloppy again" is not and should never be in a file.
Common problems
- A note with no reference to a location.
- A reply that restates the note instead of answering it.
- "Cleared" with no evidence referenced.
- Changing the workpaper without recording what changed.
- Two notes that contradict each other and no record of which governs.
- Notes held in chat or email instead of the file, then lost.
If notes live in the firm's workspace, keep them there. If a decision was made on a call, write a short note in the file recording what was decided, with the date and who was present.
FAQ
How long should a note be?
As long as it takes to say where, what, and what is needed. Usually two or three sentences.
Should I delete cleared notes?
No. Follow the firm's rule, which is normally to mark them cleared and keep them until the final file is assembled and retained.
Can the preparer clear their own note?
Usually the person who raised the note decides whether it is cleared. Follow the firm's procedure.
Is a note required on every workpaper?
No. The standard does not require evidence of review on every individual working paper; it requires documenting what work was reviewed, who reviewed it and when (AU-C 230.A15).
Sources
- AICPA, AU-C Section 230, Audit Documentation (AU-C sections, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective
- AICPA, AU-C Section 220, Quality Management for an Engagement (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 90, Review of Financial Statements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective