The test a workpaper has to pass
US rule. AU-C 230 asks for audit documentation sufficient to enable an experienced auditor, having no previous connection with the audit, to understand the nature, timing and extent of procedures performed, the results of the procedures and the evidence obtained, and significant findings or issues, the conclusions reached and significant judgments (AU-C 230.08). In a review engagement under the SSARS, the equivalent standard speaks of an experienced accountant with no previous connection to the review (AR-C 90.137).
A four-part layout, purpose, source, procedure, conclusion, is a way to meet that test consistently. It is a practice, not a requirement of the standard, and firms use their own templates. Where a firm template exists, use it and apply this layout inside it. General information.
The four parts
Purpose
One or two sentences: what the workpaper is for. Name the area, the period, and the assertion or risk it addresses if the plan names one.
Example: "To support the existence and accuracy of trade receivables at 31 December, by agreeing the receivables listing to the ledger and testing selected balances."
A reader should know within ten seconds what question this page answers.
Source
Where the starting figures and populations come from. Reference the trial balance, the ledger report, the client schedule or the third-party document, with the date and version. State how completeness of the population was checked, such as footing the listing and agreeing its total to the ledger.
Example: "Receivables listing at 31 Dec, version dated 14 Jan (ref D-1), total 412,300, agreed to trial balance line 1200."
Procedure
What you did, to which items, in enough detail to repeat. The standard requires recording the identifying characteristics of the specific items or matters tested (AU-C 230.09a). Its explanatory material gives examples: for a test of all items over an amount, record the scope and identify the population; for a systematic sample, the source, starting point and interval; for an inquiry, the dates, names and what was asked (AU-C 230.A14).
Example: "Selected all balances over the stated threshold, listed at D-2. For each, agreed to subsequent cash receipt or sent a positive confirmation request (D-4)."
Conclusion
What the evidence supports, in the terms of the purpose. Include exceptions and how each was resolved or why it remains open. Where the firm's method asks the preparer for a conclusion, write it. The reviewer decides whether it stands.
Example: "Except for the 4,000 difference on customer 14, explained at D-4 note 7 as a payment in transit, all selected balances agreed to a receipt or a confirmation. No adjustment proposed."
If you cannot reach a conclusion, say what is missing: "Not concluded. Confirmation for customers 22 and 31 outstanding; alternative procedures not yet performed."
What else goes on the page
- Header: entity, period, area, workpaper reference.
- Who and when: who performed the work and the date it was completed, and who reviewed and when (AU-C 230.09b and c). Use the firm's initials and date format.
- Tick mark legend: each mark defined once, on the page or in a referenced index.
- Cross-references: each figure carried in from or out to another workpaper is referenced both ways.
- Contracts: for inspection of significant contracts, the standard requires abstracts or copies in the file (AU-C 230.10).
Worked example
Illustrative example, invented figures. Prepaid insurance check, 31 December.
Header: Entity: Sample Co. Period: year ended 31 December. Area: prepaid expenses. Ref: G-3. Prepared by: [initials], [date].
Purpose: To support the prepaid insurance balance at 31 December by recalculating the unexpired portion of the annual premium.
Source: Policy invoice (G-3.1): premium 12,000 for 12 months from 1 April. Ledger balance for prepaid insurance 3,000 (trial balance line 1310).
Procedure:
- Agreed premium and policy dates to the invoice (G-3.1). ✓
- Recalculated monthly cost: 12,000 ÷ 12 = 1,000. ✓
- Months expired to 31 December: April to December, 9 months; expense to date 9,000. ✓
- Unexpired: 12,000 − 9,000 = 3,000. ✓
- Agreed to ledger balance. ✓
Conclusion: Recalculated balance 3,000 agrees to ledger 3,000. No difference. Prepaid insurance supported.
Legend: ✓ agreed to source or recalculated without difference.
Sign-off: Prepared [initials, date]. Reviewed [name, date].
A reader with no knowledge of Sample Co. can repeat every step and reach the same figure. That is the standard in action.
Self-review before you hand it over
- Does the purpose say what the page is for?
- Does every starting figure have a source and a date?
- Can someone repeat the procedure from what is written?
- Are the items tested identifiable?
- Is each tick mark defined?
- Does every conclusion follow from the work above it?
- Are exceptions listed and resolved or flagged?
- Do the figures agree to other workpapers and the trial balance?
- Are sign-offs and dates complete?
- Is there anything on the page that is wrong or superseded, and if so, is its treatment explained? The standard does not require keeping documents that are incorrect or superseded (AU-C 230.A17), but it does ask for documentation of how inconsistencies on significant matters were addressed (AU-C 230.12).
Things to leave out
It is neither necessary nor practicable to document every matter considered or judgment made. The standard also says it is unnecessary to document separately, as in a checklist, compliance with matters shown by documents already in the file (AU-C 230.A9). Leave out narrative that adds nothing. A shorter page that passes the test beats a longer one that hides it.
Timing
Write the page while you do the work. The standard requires timely preparation (AU-C 230.07), and documentation prepared at the time or shortly after is likely to be more accurate (AU-C 230.A3). Do not leave sign-offs and conclusions for the end of the file. After the documentation completion date, changes require documented reasons, who made them and when (AU-C 230.18), so get the page right before then.
FAQ
How long should a workpaper be?
Long enough to pass the test and short enough for a reviewer to read in a few minutes. One area often needs one page of narrative and the supporting schedules.
Do I need a conclusion on every page?
Follow the firm's template. Where a conclusion is asked for, write it. A page without one leaves the reviewer guessing.
Can I use a different layout?
Use the firm's. The four parts can sit inside most templates.
What if the procedure changed halfway?
Write what you actually did and why it changed. The record is of work performed, not of the plan.
Sources
- AICPA, AU-C Section 230, Audit Documentation (AU-C sections, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 90, Review of Financial Statements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective