Clear an audit finding with evidence and a note

Seven steps to clear a review note or audit finding: find the cause, get evidence, change the workpaper, write the reply, let the reviewer decide.

US rule · Updated November 5, 2026

What this tutorial covers

US rule for the documentation points; country-neutral as practice. A finding is any point raised against work in a file: a reviewer's note, a difference found in a procedure, an exception on a confirmation, an open item on a checklist. Clearing it means the file shows what the issue was, what evidence resolved it, what changed, and that the reviewer accepted the resolution. This tutorial walks through that in seven steps with one worked example.

General information. The firm's methodology sets note formats and who may clear what.

Why the record matters

For an audit, the standard asks the auditor to document significant findings or issues, the conclusions reached and the significant professional judgments (AU-C 230.08c). If information is inconsistent with the final conclusion on a significant matter, the auditor documents how the inconsistency was addressed (AU-C 230.12). And the file must show who reviewed the work and when (AU-C 230.09c). A finding cleared with one word leaves none of that.

The seven steps

1. Read the finding as written

Restate it in your own words in a line: "Customer 14 confirmed 8,200; ledger is 12,200; difference 4,000." If you cannot restate it, ask the reviewer before doing anything.

2. Work out the cause before you gather evidence

Identify the likely cause from the file: timing, error, missing item, disagreement over terms, misposting. The cause tells you which evidence will resolve it. A timing cause needs dates from two sources. An error needs the transaction. A disagreement needs the contract.

3. Get evidence from the right source

Prefer evidence from outside the entity and documents over explanations. The confirmation standard notes that audit evidence is more reliable when obtained from external parties and when in documentary form (AU-C 505.02). If the only support is the client's statement, say that in the note, and ask the reviewer how to proceed.

Reference every piece of evidence in the file with its own index. "Per client" is not a reference.

4. Decide what the evidence shows

Three outcomes are possible.

  • Explained, no change. The evidence shows the original figure was right and the difference is a reconciling item.
  • Error, change needed. The evidence shows a misstatement or an error in your work. Propose the correction, with amounts.
  • Unresolved. The evidence does not settle it. State what is missing and who has been asked.

Do not pick the outcome you prefer. If the evidence is mixed, say so. The decision whether a difference is a misstatement, and whether it matters to the statements, belongs to the engagement team and ultimately the signer. You record the facts and give your reading.

5. Change the workpaper

Update the schedule, the reference, the tick mark or the conclusion so the workpaper now shows the resolved position. Do not delete the original line if it shows the difference. Add the resolution beside it. If a superseded document is simply wrong, the standard does not require keeping it (AU-C 230.A17), but keep whatever shows how the matter was addressed.

6. Write the reply

Use three parts in the same place as the note: what you did, what you found, and the reference. Add your date and initials.

7. Hand it back

Mark the note ready for review and tell the reviewer. Do not mark it cleared yourself unless the firm's procedure says you may. If the firm's convention is that the reviewer clears, wait for that.

Worked example

Illustrative example, invented names and figures.

Finding (WP D-4, receivables confirmations): "Customer 14: confirmation reply shows 8,200; ledger 12,200. Difference 4,000. Investigate and clear."

Step 1. Restated: difference of 4,000 on one customer.

Step 2. Likely cause: a payment in transit at year-end, because the reply carries a handwritten note about a December payment.

Step 3. Evidence collected:

  • The customer's reply (D-4.14) states an invoice for 4,000 was paid on 30 December.
  • The January bank statement (D-1.3) shows a 4,000 credit on 3 January.
  • The cash receipts journal (D-4.15) records the receipt on 3 January.

Step 4. Result: the entity had not received the funds at 31 December. The ledger balance of 12,200 was correct at that date. 12,200 − 4,000 = 8,200, which is the customer's figure. The difference is a reconciling item caused by payment timing. No adjustment is proposed on this evidence.

Step 5. Workpaper updated: the exceptions column shows "4,000, payment in transit, see D-4.14 to D-4.15" and the arithmetic of the reconciliation.

Step 6. Reply written:

D-4 note 7. Customer 14 confirmed 8,200 vs ledger 12,200, difference 4,000. Customer states payment of invoice 8841 on 30 Dec (D-4.14). Bank credit 3 Jan (D-1.3) and receipt recorded 3 Jan (D-4.15). Funds not received at 31 Dec, so ledger balance is right at year-end and the difference is timing. 12,200 − 4,000 = 8,200 agrees to the reply. No adjustment proposed. Prepared [initials, date]. Ready for review.

Step 7. The reviewer reads the reply, checks the three references, and either clears the note or asks a follow-up. The confirmations standard requires the auditor to investigate exceptions to determine whether they indicate misstatements (AU-C 505.14); the reviewer's clearance is the record that the investigation was done.

Traps

  • Explaining with the client's story only. If the only source is a client email, mark it as such.
  • Clearing and moving on. If the cause could affect other items (the same payment timing on other customers), flag it.
  • Changing the number to make the difference disappear.
  • Over-answering. A reply that argues the whole audit approach buries the point. Answer the note.
  • Under-answering. "See attached" with no explanation.
  • Editing after the file is closed. Once the firm marks the file complete, changes need the firm's process, with reasons, who and when (AU-C 230.18).

When you cannot clear it

Say so early. A good unresolved reply reads: "Could not obtain support for the 1,150 reconciling item. Requested the cheque register from [name] on [date]; no reply by [date]. Item remains open; effect on balance if the item is invalid: 1,150 overstatement of cash." The reviewer can then decide what to do. A silent open item gets found late and costs the file time.

FAQ

Who decides if the finding is a misstatement?

The engagement team, and for matters affecting the report, the signer. Your reply states the facts and your reading.

How many pieces of evidence do I need?

Enough that another auditor could reach the same conclusion from the file. For the example above, three references.

Can I clear a note raised by someone more senior?

Reply and mark it ready. The person who raised it, or the firm's procedure, decides clearance.

What if I disagree with the finding?

Say so with evidence. Let the reviewer decide, and make sure the disagreement and resolution are visible in the file.

Sources

Last verified November 20, 2026. Sources checked by the editorial team; not yet reviewed by a named professional. General information, not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Related pages

Terms used on this page

Engagement team

Join the CORAA CPA network waitlist

CORAA prepares audit files for US CPA firms. Network members are independent contractors who clear what the software flags, with evidence and a note, paid per file under a contractor agreement.

  • Files are offered to you; you accept or decline
  • No exclusivity: you can work for others
  • The firm reviews and signs; CORAA never does

* required