What a review is
US rule. A review under the AICPA's Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services (SSARS) is an engagement in which the accountant expresses a conclusion on financial statements based on limited assurance (AR-C 90.03). The accountant performs primarily analytical procedures and inquiries to obtain sufficient appropriate review evidence (AR-C 90.04). It is less than an audit and more than a compilation.
The firm's engagement partner or signer owns the review and the report. A freelancer prepares and organises support under the firm's direction. This page explains the file you would help build. It is general information about AR-C 90, and the firm's own methodology and the current text of the standard govern. The standard also contains requirements about engagement acceptance, planning, reporting and communication that this page does not cover.
Independence comes first
Unlike a compilation, a review requires independence. The accountant must be independent of the entity, and if independence is impaired during the engagement the accountant should withdraw (AR-C 90.10). A compilation, by contrast, requires only a determination about whether the accountant is independent (AR-C 80.07), and a preparation engagement does not require that determination (AR-C 70.03).
For a contributor, the practical step is the per-file independence check before you touch the file. If you have any relationship with the entity that the firm does not know about, say so before starting.
The core procedures
AR-C 90 sets out the evidence the accountant obtains. The parts that most affect file preparation are these.
Understanding the entity
The accountant obtains knowledge about the entity, including an understanding of its business and of the accounting principles and practices it uses, enough to identify where material misstatements are more likely and to design procedures for those areas (AR-C 90.22). Prior-year files, the engagement letter, the chart of accounts and management's descriptions help you build this. Record the sources.
Analytical procedures
The accountant applies analytical procedures to the financial statements to identify relationships and individual items that appear unusual and that may indicate a material misstatement. Those procedures include comparing the financial statements to comparable information from the prior period, considering plausible relationships among financial and non-financial information, and comparing recorded amounts or ratios to expectations the accountant develops (AR-C 90.26).
In the file, an analytical procedure needs the following to be reproducible:
- The account or ratio examined.
- The current figure and the comparison figure.
- The expectation, and where it came from.
- The difference, and the threshold used to investigate it.
- The explanation obtained, who gave it, and what supports it.
Illustrative example, invented figures: payroll expense rose from 180,000 to 216,000. The increase is 36,000, or 20% of 180,000. Management explains that two roles were added in the second quarter. The file should then record who gave the explanation and when, and the reviewer will want to see whether it is reasonable against other information, such as a headcount list. The standard asks the accountant to consider the reasonableness and consistency of management's answers; it does not require corroborating every answer with other evidence (AR-C 90.30). Keep a record of what you did consider.
Inquiries
The accountant inquires of members of management with responsibility for financial and accounting matters (AR-C 90.29). Prepare the inquiry list from the standard's requirements and the firm's template. Record the date, the person, the question and the answer. Where an answer is surprising or inconsistent with other information, tell the reviewer. Whether an answer needs further follow-up is the accountant's judgment under AR-C 90.30.
Reading the statements
The accountant reads the financial statements and considers whether any information has come to attention indicating that they do not conform to the applicable financial reporting framework (AR-C 90.31). A tie-out of figures, notes and disclosures supports this. See the tie-out page.
Agreeing to the records
The accountant obtains evidence that the financial statements agree or reconcile with the accounting records (AR-C 90.41). A trial balance to statements tie-out, with references, is the usual evidence. Prepare it early and keep it updated as adjustments are posted.
When something looks wrong
If the accountant becomes aware of matters suggesting the statements may be materially misstated, the accountant designs and performs additional procedures (AR-C 90.42). Report any such matter to the reviewer promptly. Do not decide yourself that it is immaterial.
Written representations
Written representations are necessary information and count as review evidence (AR-C 90.58). They are requested from members of management with appropriate responsibilities and knowledge (AR-C 90.59). You may be asked to prepare the draft letter from the firm's template, track dates and signatures, and check that the letter covers all periods and statements under review. The dates and content are decisions for the firm. Your job is to track and check.
Review documentation
The standard says the accountant should prepare review documentation in a timely manner, sufficient to enable an experienced accountant with no previous connection to the review to understand the nature, timing and extent of procedures, the evidence obtained and the conclusions, and significant matters and judgments (AR-C 90.137). The documentation also includes the engagement letter or other written agreement with management (AR-C 90.138).
A practical file for a review contains:
- The engagement letter or written agreement.
- Independence documentation.
- Understanding of the entity.
- The materiality determination, which the standard requires (AR-C 90.19), and planning notes where the firm's methodology requires them.
- The trial balance, adjusting entries and the tie to the statements.
- Analytical procedures with expectations and explanations.
- Inquiry records.
- Representation letter.
- Significant matters and how they were resolved.
- The draft statements and report.
- Review notes and their clearance.
What a freelance contributor typically does
- Builds the trial balance to statements tie-out.
- Drafts analytical procedure workpapers with expectations from prior-year data and flags differences.
- Prepares inquiry schedules for the engagement team to complete.
- Checks the notes against the schedule support.
- Tracks open items and representations.
What a contributor does not do: decide the conclusion, decide which departures need a modified report, communicate with the client unless asked, or sign anything.
Differences from an audit file
A review does not rest on the same evidence as an audit: the accountant performs primarily analytical procedures and inquiries (AR-C 90.04). That does not mean a thin file. The file must still let a reader see what the accountant did and why it supports the limited-assurance conclusion. If you are unsure which level of support the firm wants, ask for an example of a prior file.
FAQ
Do I need independence to prepare a review file?
The accountant who issues the review must be independent. If you work on the engagement team, the firm's independence rules apply to you. Complete the firm's per-file check.
What if analytical procedures show a large unexplained difference?
Document it and tell the reviewer. Whether the matter calls for additional procedures is the accountant's decision (AR-C 90.42).
Is a review file the same as a compilation file?
No. A compilation file at minimum includes the engagement letter, the statements and the report (AR-C 80.40). A review file contains evidence of the procedures and conclusions (AR-C 90.137).
Where is the standard?
AICPA publishes the AR-C sections in its currently effective SSARS download, linked below.
Sources
- AICPA, AR-C Section 90, Review of Financial Statements (SSARS, currently effective): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective
- AICPA, AR-C Section 80, Compilation Engagements (same download): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-ssarss-currently-effective