Independence checks before every file: a worked example

An illustrative walk through the checks a freelancer runs before taking an audit file: investments, balances, business ties, fees and the written answer.

US rule · Updated November 20, 2026

US rule, with an illustrative example. The company, the firm and the people below are invented. The rules cited are real; the example only shows how a freelancer can apply them in order. General information, not legal advice.

The rule in brief

Independence is judged against the rules that apply to the engagement: the AICPA Code, any stricter state board rule, and, for companies that file with the SEC, the SEC's independence rule (17 CFR 210.2-01). That SEC rule asks whether the accountant can exercise objective and impartial judgment, and whether a reasonable investor with full knowledge of the facts would think so. It names financial relationships, business relationships and contingent fees among the things that can break independence.

Who it binds

The firm and engagement partner own the determination. An individual from another firm or service provider who performs audit procedures can be part of the engagement team (AU-C 220, paragraph .A17), and the AICPA Code's attest engagement team includes contractors retained by the firm who participate in the engagement (ET sec. 0.400.05). So the checks below are yours to run and report. The firm decides what the answers mean.

The example: an illustrative scenario

Illustrative. A firm, Lakeside & Pryor, offers you the inventory testing on the audit of "Northgate Components, Inc." The firm sends the client name, its parent and two subsidiaries, and its bank.

Check 1: investments. You look at every account you hold. A target-date fund inside your retirement account holds a small amount of Northgate stock. SEC paragraph (c)(1) covers direct and material indirect financial interests, including some interests held through intermediaries. (If the client does not file with the SEC, the AICPA Code's own independence interpretations apply instead; the firm will know which.) Whether this one is material for this engagement is the firm's question. Your job is to report it, with the fund name.

Check 2: loans and balances. You have no loan with Northgate or its lender. Your business account is at the client's bank, and the balance is within the bank's insured limit. The SEC rule treats a savings or checking account at a bank that is an audit client as a financial relationship if the balance exceeds the amount insured by the FDIC or a similar insurer (paragraph (c)(1)(ii)(B)). Here the bank is not the audit client, so that paragraph does not apply directly. You still list the account, so the firm can see it.

Check 3: business relationships. Two years ago you did a one-off bookkeeping clean-up for a Northgate subsidiary. The SEC rule covers business relationships with the client and its decision-makers (paragraph (c)(3)), and the AICPA Code has separate guidance on nonattest services for attest clients (ET sec. 1.295.040). You report the prior work, with dates and what you did.

Check 4: your fee. The firm offers a fixed amount per file. A fee that depends on the result of the audit would be a different matter, because the SEC rule treats a contingent fee as a reason independence is not met (paragraph (c)(5)), and the AICPA Code's Contingent Fees Rule (ET sec. 1.510.001) bars a member from performing services for a contingent fee for an audit client. Yours is fixed, so you note that.

Check 5: relationships and changes. You name any close personal ties to Northgate's officers. You also agree to tell the firm if anything changes, because the partner is expected to remain alert to breaches during the engagement (AU-C 220, paragraph .19).

The written answer. You send the firm a short list: the fund, the bank account, the prior bookkeeping work and the fee basis. The firm replies in a day and says what it requires, which here could be disposing of the fund position before you start, or giving the inventory testing to someone else. You did not decide that, and you did not need to. You reported, the firm evaluated.

What to do

  1. Ask for the client, parent, subsidiaries, bank and key officers before you answer.
  2. Run each check against all your accounts, not just the ones you think of first.
  3. Report anything that touches the client, even if you think it is small.
  4. Do not start work until the firm gives you a written go-ahead.
  5. Keep a copy of what you sent and the date.

Where the official text is

SEC 17 CFR 210.2-01 on eCFR. AICPA Code of Professional Conduct online (independence rule and interpretations). AU-C section 220 on the AICPA standards pages.

Sources

Last verified November 20, 2026. Sources checked by the editorial team; not yet reviewed by a named professional. General information, not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Related pages

Terms used on this page

Engagement team, Contingent fee

Join the CORAA CPA network waitlist

CORAA prepares audit files for US CPA firms. Network members are independent contractors who clear what the software flags, with evidence and a note, paid per file under a contractor agreement.

  • Files are offered to you; you accept or decline
  • No exclusivity: you can work for others
  • The firm reviews and signs; CORAA never does

* required