Independence is the rule that most often catches freelancers by surprise. A firm that offers you part of an audit file is relying on you to be as independent of that client as the firm's own partners are. This page explains where that duty comes from, who it reaches, and what a careful freelancer does before opening a file.
This is general information about professional standards, not legal advice. Where a rule differs by state, by engagement type or by regulator, the text of the rule that applies to your file controls.
The rule in brief
US rule. Under the AICPA's auditing standard on quality management for an engagement (AU-C section 220, from SAS No. 146 as amended by SAS No. 149, effective for audits of periods beginning on or after 15 December 2025), an audit must be performed in line with "relevant ethical requirements", including those on independence. The standard defines relevant ethical requirements as the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct together with any more restrictive rules of the state boards of accountancy and regulatory agencies that apply to the engagement.
Three points follow from the standard's text:
- The engagement partner must understand the relevant ethical requirements, including independence, that apply to the engagement (paragraph .16).
- The engagement partner takes responsibility for the other members of the engagement team having been made aware of those requirements and the firm's related policies, including how threats are identified, evaluated and addressed, and what team members must do when they become aware of a breach (paragraph .17).
- Before the auditor's report is dated, the engagement partner takes responsibility for determining whether the relevant ethical requirements, including independence, have been fulfilled (paragraph .21).
The AICPA Code reaches the same people from its side. Its Independence Rule (ET sec. 1.200.001) applies to covered members, and a covered member includes any individual on the attest engagement team (ET sec. 0.400.14). The attest engagement team "includes all employees and contractors retained by the firm who participate in the attest engagement" (ET sec. 0.400.05). A revised wording of that definition takes effect for attest engagements beginning on or after 15 December 2026; it keeps the reference to contractors.
The firm signs the report and carries that duty. You carry a share of it for the work you touch, because you are one of the people the partner relies on.
Who it binds
The auditing standard defines the engagement team as all partners and staff performing the audit and any other individuals who perform audit procedures on the engagement. Two groups are carved out: an auditor's external specialist, and internal auditors who give direct assistance.
The application guidance then speaks to freelancers directly, without using the word. It says an engagement team may include individuals who perform audit procedures and who come from a network firm, from a firm that is not a network firm, or from another service provider (paragraph .A17). It also says the team can be organised across different locations and in groups, and that any individual who performs audit procedures is a member (.A15).
So the test is what you do, not what your contract is called. If you perform audit procedures on the file, such as testing, confirmations or analytical work, expect the firm to treat you as a member of the engagement team and to apply its independence process to you.
The guidance also marks two edges:
- A person whose involvement is limited to consultation is not a member of the engagement team (.A19).
- An engagement quality reviewer is not a member of the engagement team, but is subject to the same relevant ethical requirements as its members, including independence (.A20). The Code's attest engagement team definition expressly includes those who perform engagement quality reviews.
A freelancer who only answers a technical question sits in the first group. A freelancer who tests a sample and writes up the result sits in the engagement team. The firm decides which applies on its file; ask early.
What "relevant ethical requirements" can include
The standard says relevant requirements may vary with the engagement. It gives the example that some independence requirements apply only to audits of depository institutions or employee benefit plans (.A40). That is why a freelancer who moves from one client type to another cannot assume last month's answer still holds.
The AICPA Code also has interpretations on specific situations. AU-C 220 itself points to one: the interpretation titled "General Requirements for Performing Nonattest Services" (ET sec. 1.295.040) gives guidance on safeguards that reduce threats to independence when a firm performs nonattest services for an attest client (.A46). If you also do bookkeeping or other non-audit work for the same client, tell the firm; it changes the analysis.
US rule: the SEC standard, where it applies
Some files are for companies that file with the SEC. For those, the SEC has its own independence rule, 17 CFR 210.2-01. In summary:
- An accountant is not independent if the accountant cannot exercise objective and impartial judgment on all issues in the engagement, or if a reasonable investor with full knowledge of the facts would conclude the accountant cannot. The SEC looks at all relationships with the audit client, not only those tied to SEC filings (paragraph (b)).
- Financial relationships can break independence. The rule covers direct and material indirect financial interests, including investments held through intermediaries, loans, and certain account balances (paragraph (c)(1)).
- Business relationships with the client or with people in decision-making roles at the client are covered (paragraph (c)(3)).
- A contingent fee or commission, paid by the client or to the client, is covered (paragraph (c)(5)).
The rule text speaks of the "accounting firm" and its associated entities. It does not say how a freelancer is treated. Do not assume you are outside it. Ask the firm how it applies the rule to people it engages.
Country-neutral: the threats-and-safeguards method
Outside the US, and in many firms' own policies, independence is analysed with the method in the IESBA International Code of Ethics. IESBA describes the Code as a principles-based framework built on five fundamental principles: integrity, objectivity, professional competence and due care, confidentiality, and professional behaviour. The conceptual framework asks you to do three things:
- Identify threats to compliance.
- Evaluate them using the reasonable and informed third party test.
- Address them by eliminating the circumstance, applying safeguards, or declining or ending the engagement.
IESBA lists five threat categories: self-interest, self-review, advocacy, familiarity and intimidation. Each has an obvious freelance version:
- Self-interest: you hold shares in the client, or the client offers you more work if the result looks good.
- Self-review: you prepared part of the client's records and are now asked to test them.
- Advocacy: you are asked to argue the client's position to a third party.
- Familiarity: you have a long personal relationship with the client's finance lead.
- Intimidation: a client contact pressures you over a finding.
Check your own regulator. If you are a member of a professional body outside the US, your body's code and any local law set the binding rule. IESBA is the model many bodies follow, not a substitute for your own rules. The IESBA page above links the current edition.
What to do before you accept a file
Do these in order, and keep a short note of each answer.
- Ask what the engagement is. Audit, review, compilation, agreed-upon procedures and tax work are different engagements with different rules. Ask the firm which ethical requirements it says apply.
- Ask for the client name and the related parties it will share. You cannot check what you have not been told. Get the entity, its parent and subsidiaries, and its key officers if the firm will share them.
- List your own relationships. Investments, including funds and retirement accounts that may hold the client; loans and balances with the client or its lender; business dealings; current or past work for the client; and close personal relationships with people at the client.
- Check how you are paid. Pay set by file, by hours or by milestone is routine. Pay that depends on the result of the audit is a different matter, covered by the AICPA Code's Contingent Fees Rule (ET sec. 1.510.001) and by the SEC rule above.
- Answer the firm's independence form or confirmation in writing. AU-C 220 notes that a firm may communicate the independence requirements, obtain documented confirmations of compliance, and set procedures for people to communicate relationships that may threaten independence and to promptly communicate breaches (.A42). For someone who is not firm personnel, it says the firm may accept evidence of independence in other ways, such as a written confirmation (.A26). Give a true answer, and give it before you start.
- Tell the firm if anything changes. A new investment, a new client of your own, or a new relationship mid-file is a reportable change. The partner is expected to remain alert for breaches throughout the engagement (paragraph .19).
- If you are unsure, say so. An uncertain answer the firm can evaluate is better than a confident wrong one.
Two short scenarios
Illustrative scenario 1. A firm offers you the receivables testing on an audit file. You check your accounts and find a broad index fund that holds a small amount of the client's stock. You tell the firm. The firm, not you, decides whether the interest is one that matters under the rules that apply to the engagement, and whether to proceed, change the assignment or pick someone else. You do not start until it answers.
Illustrative scenario 2. After two weeks on a file, the client's controller offers you a separate paid project on their month-end close. You say you will answer once you have spoken to the firm, and you do so the same day. Whether the extra work can be taken depends on the nonattest services analysis and on the engagement type. Taking it first and telling the firm later is the pattern to avoid.
Frequently asked questions
Does independence apply to me if I only review the firm's work after it is done?
Yes, if you are the engagement quality reviewer. AU-C 220 says the reviewer is not a member of the engagement team but is subject to the same relevant ethical requirements, including independence, and the AICPA Code's attest engagement team definition includes those who perform engagement quality reviews. For other review roles, ask the firm which requirements it applies to you.
Does it matter that I am a contractor, not part of the firm?
No, not in the way you might hope. The AICPA Code's attest engagement team definition names "contractors retained by the firm" alongside employees, and the auditing standard's definition looks at who performs audit procedures, including people from another firm or service provider. Your contract type does not take you out of either description.
Is independence only about money?
No. The SEC rule covers business relationships and contingent fees as well as financial interests, and the IESBA method includes familiarity and intimidation. A non-financial relationship can be a threat.
Can I fix a problem after I find it?
Tell the firm at once. AU-C 220 sets out what the engagement partner does when a matter indicating a threat comes to attention: evaluate it under the firm's policies and take appropriate action (paragraph .18). The decision is the firm's.
Where the official text is
- AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (online): the independence rule and its interpretations, and the definitions in ET sec. 0.400.
- AICPA, AU-C section 220 and the other AU-C sections on the AICPA standards pages.
- SEC, 17 CFR 210.2-01 on eCFR.
- IESBA International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants, including the International Independence Standards.
- Your state board of accountancy, for any rule more restrictive than the AICPA Code.
Sources
- AICPA, AU-C section 220, Quality Management for an Engagement Conducted in Accordance With GAAS (SAS No. 146, as amended by SAS No. 149): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/download/aicpa-statements-on-auditing-standards-currently-effective (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- SEC, 17 CFR 210.2-01, Qualifications of accountants: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/chapter-II/part-210/section-210.2-01 (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- IESBA, International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants: https://www.ethicsboard.org/iesba-code (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- AICPA, Code of Professional Conduct (online): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/landing/code-of-professional-conduct (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- AICPA, Code of Professional Conduct, full text updated through July 2026 (PDF hosted by the Minnesota Board of Accountancy): https://mn.gov/boa/assets/AICPA%20Code%20of%20Professional%20Conduct_tcm1233-764395.pdf (retrieved 2026-11-20)
- AICPA Professional Ethics Division, Revised definition of attest engagement team (17 August 2026): https://www.aicpa-cima.com/news/download/revised-def-engagement-team-2026 (retrieved 2026-11-20)