CECL scope and the expected credit loss model

What Subtopic 326-20 covers, what it excludes, and the measurement principles: lifetime losses, past events, current conditions, forecasts and reversion.

4 min read · CORAA Team
Lesson 10 of 14 · 0 of 14 complete
In this lesson you will
  • Identify assets inside and outside the scope of 326-20
  • Explain how the allowance is measured and recorded under 326-20-30-1
  • Apply the information requirements: history, current conditions, forecasts and reversion
  • Evaluate when an expected loss of zero is supportable

Scope

Subtopic 326-20 applies to (326-20-15-2):

  • financial assets measured at amortized cost, including financing receivables, held-to-maturity debt securities, receivables from revenue transactions under Topic 606 and Topic 610, reinsurance receivables, and receivables from repurchase and securities lending agreements,
  • net investments in leases recognized by a lessor under Topic 842,
  • off-balance-sheet credit exposures not accounted for as insurance, such as loan commitments and financial guarantees.

It does not apply to (326-20-15-3) financial assets measured at fair value through net income, available-for-sale debt securities, participant loans of defined contribution plans, policy loan receivables of insurers, a not-for-profit's pledges receivable, loans and receivables between entities under common control, or receivables from operating leases (added by ASU 2018-19).

Two exclusions trip people up. Intercompany loans between commonly controlled entities need no CECL allowance, though collectibility still matters for other reasons. AFS securities follow Subtopic 326-30 (Lesson 13).

The allowance

The allowance for credit losses is a valuation account deducted from amortized cost to present the net amount expected to be collected. At each reporting date the entity records credit loss expense or a reversal for the amount needed to adjust the allowance to management's current estimate (326-20-30-1 and 326-20-35-1). There is no probable threshold. Losses are recognized on day one for newly originated or acquired assets.

Contractual term

Losses are estimated over the contractual term, considering prepayments (326-20-30-6). The term is not extended for expected extensions, renewals and modifications unless the extension or renewal option is in the original or modified contract at the reporting date and is not unconditionally cancellable by the entity. A three-year note with no renewal clause is measured over three years even if the borrower always renews.

Information to use

Under 326-20-30-7 the entity considers available information about past events, current conditions, and reasonable and supportable forecasts. It need not search for information not reasonably available without undue cost and effort, and internal information may be sufficient.

  • History. Historical loss experience on assets with similar risk characteristics is the usual starting point. Adjust it for differences in underwriting, portfolio mix and asset term (326-20-30-8).
  • Not history alone. An entity shall not rely solely on past events. Historical rates are adjusted for how current conditions and forecasts differ from the period the history covers, through qualitative or quantitative adjustments (326-20-30-9).
  • Reversion. Beyond the period for which the entity can make reasonable and supportable forecasts, it reverts to historical loss information (326-20-30-9).

Remote risk and zero loss

The estimate reflects the risk of loss even when that risk is remote (326-20-30-10). An entity is not required to record losses where history adjusted for current conditions and forecasts results in an expectation that nonpayment of the amortized cost basis is zero. Collateral value alone does not support zero; the nature of the collateral and potential changes in its value must be considered. The exception is the collateral maintenance provisions in 326-20-35-4 through 35-6.

Off-balance-sheet exposures

For unfunded commitments the entity estimates losses over the contractual period in which it is exposed to credit risk through a present obligation to extend credit, unless that obligation is unconditionally cancellable by the issuer. The result is recorded as a liability for credit losses, not as part of the asset allowance (326-20-30-11).

Audit angle

Start by testing scope: obtain a listing of financial assets and commitments, map each to in-scope or excluded, and check that exclusions such as common control receivables are real. The CECL private company guide summarizes the common pools.

Worked example

Mapping the scope at Bellwether Ag Supply Co.

Bellwether Ag Supply Co. reports these balances at year-end: trade receivables $3.2 million; a $400,000 note from a farm customer; $1.1 million of corporate bonds classified as held to maturity; $600,000 of municipal bonds classified as available for sale; a $250,000 loan to a sister company that shares the same controlling parent; and a $500,000 unfunded line of credit Bellwether extended to a dealer that it cannot cancel.

In 326-20 scope: trade receivables, the customer note, the HTM bonds and the unfunded line of credit (an off-balance-sheet exposure not accounted for as insurance).

Out of 326-20 scope: the AFS municipal bonds, which go to Subtopic 326-30, and the sister company loan, which is excluded as a loan between entities under common control.

Conclusion: Bellwether needs allowances on four populations. The HTM bonds and the line of credit were missing from its CECL memo. The auditor raises both and requests a separate liability for the unfunded commitment.

Self-check

Answer each question before you open the answer.

  1. Does a loan between two entities under common control need a CECL allowance?

    Show answer

    No. Loans and receivables between entities under common control are excluded from 326-20 by 326-20-15-3.

  2. Can an entity estimate the allowance using historical loss rates without adjustment?

    Show answer

    No. 326-20-30-9 says an entity shall not rely solely on past events and must consider adjusting history for current conditions and reasonable and supportable forecasts.

  3. What happens for periods beyond the reasonable and supportable forecast?

    Show answer

    The entity reverts to historical loss information (326-20-30-9).

  4. Is collateral value alone enough to record zero expected credit loss?

    Show answer

    No. Under 326-20-30-10 the entity also considers the nature of the collateral, potential future changes in its value and historical loss information for similar collateral. The only exception is the collateral maintenance provisions in 326-20-35-4 through 35-6.

Sources

Back to the syllabus

Standards are paraphrased from the primary sources listed above; read the source before relying on a requirement. This lesson is training material, not professional advice. Report an error

For US CPA firms

Join the CORAA waitlist

CORAA AI drafts audit working papers from your client’s QuickBooks books and does the first pass: lead schedules, tie-out, memos, draft notes and letters. CORAA Network reviewers clear every finding. Your firm reviews and signs.

  • First audit free, so you can judge the quality on a real file
  • Flat fee by entity size; messy books included
  • We work only with CPA firms, never their clients
See how it works →

* required