Hourly, fixed fee and per file are three ways to deliver the same rate. They differ in one thing: who pays when the work takes longer or shorter than expected. Pick the model by looking at that risk, not by habit.
Country-neutral: the risk comparison and the conversions. US rule: the fee limits in the last section. Check your own regulator for fee rules of any other professional body.
Hourly: the buyer carries the overrun
You record time, you invoice time. If a file turns out messier than described, you are paid for the extra hours and the buyer learns the true cost.
When it fits:
- The scope has unknowns, such as a clean-up where nobody knows the state of the books.
- The buyer wants to change direction as the work goes on.
- You cannot yet estimate this type of work.
What it asks of you: honest time records kept as you go, a stated minimum billing increment, and a clear rule on what counts as billable (review notes, calls, rework you caused or did not cause). What it asks of the buyer: trust in your records, and often a cap or an estimate to stay within budget.
The weakness is that your income falls as you get faster. A person who finishes a task in three hours that used to take five is paid less for being better. That pushes experienced practitioners towards the other two models.
Fixed fee: you carry the overrun
You quote a price for a defined scope. If you finish early, you keep the difference. If the work overruns, you absorb it, unless the overrun comes from a change in scope that the agreement lets you price separately.
When it fits:
- The scope is defined and you have done similar work before.
- You have your own records showing how long that work takes.
- The buyer wants a number it can budget.
What makes it work is the scope statement. A fixed fee on a vague scope is an invitation to argue. Write what is included, what is not, what you need from the buyer and by when, how many rounds of review notes are covered, and what happens when the scope changes. The contracts section covers scope statements and change orders in detail.
The weakness is optimism. People underestimate hours on work they have not timed. Time a few engagements at an hourly rate before you convert to fixed fees, so the estimate rests on data.
Per file: a fixed fee with a standard unit
Per-file pricing sets one price for each unit of work of a defined type. A "file" could be one set of financial statements to check, one reconciliation pack, or one return to review. It works when files are similar in size and condition, and the buyer sends many of them.
It breaks when files vary. If a price is set for an average file and you receive the largest ones, the equivalent hourly rate falls. If you can choose which files to take, you may favour the easy ones, and the buyer is left with the hard ones. Both sides should know this before agreeing.
Questions that decide whether a per-file offer is sound are in the guide on judging a per-file offer. In outline: what defines a file, what size or complexity limits apply, what happens when a file exceeds them, how rework is handled, and when you are paid.
Compare the three by risk
- Hourly: buyer carries overrun; you carry the risk of unpaid time that was not agreed as billable.
- Fixed fee: you carry overrun; buyer carries the risk of paying for less work than expected if you finish early.
- Per file: you carry variation between files; buyer carries volume risk if it must keep sending work to keep you engaged.
A hybrid is common: an hourly rate with a cap for open scopes, or a fixed fee with an hourly rate for approved changes. Hybrids work when the agreement states the trigger that moves from one to the other.
Convert any offer to an hourly equivalent
The method is the same for any model:
- Estimate the hours the work will take, including review notes, communication and a margin for rework.
- Divide the price by those hours.
- Compare the result with your required rate, built as described in the main rates guide.
Illustrative example, labelled as such, in plain units. A fixed fee of 1,200 units for a task you estimate at 10 hours is 1,200 / 10 = 120 units an hour. If the task actually takes 16 hours, the realised rate is 1,200 / 16 = 75 units an hour, and the fee would have needed to be 16 x 120 = 1,920 units to hold the original rate. Run the calculation in both directions: forward to price, and backward after the work to see how the estimate performed.
The hourly-to-project converter on this site does this arithmetic for you using only the numbers you type; it stores nothing.
Pick by asking five questions
- Can I define the scope in a paragraph? If yes, fixed fee or per file are open to you. If no, stay hourly.
- Have I timed this kind of work before? If not, start hourly and collect data.
- Will the buyer change direction? If yes, hourly or fixed fee with priced changes.
- Are the files alike? If yes, per file can work. If no, set size or complexity bands or use hourly.
- Who is better placed to control the hours? Put the risk on the party that controls them.
Fee rules that apply whichever model you use
US rule: under Circular 230 section 10.27, a practitioner may not charge an unconscionable fee in connection with a matter before the IRS, and in general may not charge a contingent fee for services in connection with such a matter, with narrow exceptions set out in the section. A contingent fee is defined there as one based wholly or partly on whether a position on a tax return or other filing avoids IRS challenge or is sustained, including a fee that otherwise depends on the specific result attained. A flat fixed fee or a fixed per-file fee set before the work is not contingent in that sense. A fee that moves with the outcome of the work, such as a share of a refund, is the pattern the section targets. See the guide on contingent fees for how to check an offer.
The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct has a separate contingent-fee rule at ET 1.510.001 that binds AICPA members in public practice. Read the rule itself, and check the board that licenses you for any rule of its own.
Outside the US, check your own regulator for rules on fee arrangements.
Frequently asked questions
Which model gives the best result for an accountant?
None on its own. Hourly protects you where scope is unknown. Fixed fee rewards accurate estimating. Per file rewards volume and standard work. The best choice follows the work and your records.
Can I quote a fixed fee and still charge for extra work?
Yes, if the agreement says what counts as extra and how it is priced, and the buyer approves the change in writing before you do the work.
Should I give a discount for volume?
You can, but price it from your estimate. If volume lowers your own cost per file, share some of that. If it only gives the buyer more work for the same cost to you, do not.
Is a retainer a separate model?
A retainer is a fixed fee paid on a schedule for access to a defined amount of your time or a defined set of tasks. State what it covers and what happens to unused time.
Sources
- 31 CFR 10.27 (Circular 230): fees, including unconscionable and contingent fees. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/section-10.27
- AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, ET 1.510.001 Contingent Fees Rule. https://mn.gov/boa/assets/AICPA%20Code%20of%20Professional%20Conduct_tcm1233-764395.pdf