Why you should not charge a contingent fee on some work

What a contingent fee is under Circular 230 section 10.27, its exceptions, how pay can become contingent by accident, and where the AICPA rule sits.

US rule; elsewhere, check your own regulator · Updated November 20, 2026

A contingent fee is a fee that depends on the result. For some kinds of accounting work, US rules restrict or prohibit it. Freelancers meet the issue in two places: when they set their own price, and when a buyer proposes pay that moves with an outcome. This page explains the IRS rule in brief, shows how a contingent arrangement can appear by accident, and points to the AICPA rule.

US rule: everything about Circular 230 below. Check your own regulator for fee rules in other countries or professional bodies; this page does not summarise them.

The rule in brief

Circular 230 is the set of Treasury regulations governing practice before the IRS. Section 10.27 deals with fees. It has two parts that matter here.

First, a practitioner may not charge an unconscionable fee in connection with a matter before the IRS.

Second, in general a practitioner may not charge a contingent fee for services in connection with any matter before the IRS. The section lists exceptions:

  • Services connected with the IRS examining or challenging an original return, or an amended return or refund claim filed within 120 days of the taxpayer receiving written notice of the examination or challenge.
  • Services connected with a claim for credit or refund filed solely in connection with the determination of statutory interest or penalties the IRS assessed.
  • Services in any judicial proceeding arising under the Internal Revenue Code.

The section defines a contingent fee as one based wholly or partly on whether a position taken on a tax return or other filing avoids challenge by the IRS or is sustained. Fees set as a percentage of a refund or of tax savings fall within it, as does any fee that otherwise depends on the specific result attained. So does an arrangement under which the practitioner reimburses the client if a position is challenged or not sustained. The section also describes a "matter before the Internal Revenue Service" broadly: it includes tax planning and advice, preparing or filing returns and refund claims, and communications with or representation before the IRS. It applies to fee arrangements entered into after 26 March 2008.

This is a summary. Read the section itself before relying on it.

Who it binds

Circular 230 binds practitioners as the regulation defines them. If you are a licensed professional who practises before the IRS, treat it as binding on you. If you are an accountant who works in the background on a firm's file, the firm that deals with the IRS is in the same position, and your agreement with it should not create a fee structure that puts the firm in breach. The AICPA Code separately binds AICPA members, and it contains its own contingent-fee rule at ET 1.510.001, which applies to members in public practice. It bars a contingent fee for any professional service for a client for whom the member or the member's firm performs an audit or review of financial statements (and certain compilations and examinations of prospective financial information), and bars preparing an original or amended tax return or refund claim for a contingent fee for any client. State boards of accountancy may have rules of their own. Where more than one rule applies, you follow the strictest one that binds you or the firm you work for.

How pay becomes contingent without anyone meaning it to

Most freelancers will never write "contingent" in a contract. The risk is in the way pay is structured. Watch for these patterns:

  • Pay tied to a refund or to tax saved. A bonus or percentage linked to the size of a refund, or to how much tax a position removes, matches the definition's own examples.
  • Pay that depends on the IRS accepting a position. A "success" payment on top of a base fee, due only if a return is not challenged or a position is sustained, is based partly on whether the position holds.
  • Refunds of your fee if the position fails. An arrangement where you return fees when a position is challenged or not sustained is covered by the definition.
  • Pay that depends on a review finding the file clean. This is not a tax-return position, so section 10.27 may not be the rule at stake, but the AICPA rule and the firm's own independence and fee policies may be. Ask the firm before agreeing to it.

By contrast, a fee fixed before the work begins, whether per hour, per file or per project, and not dependent on the outcome, is not contingent in the sense of the definition above. Fixed per-file pay for reviewing preparation is an example. Whether the fee is paid should not turn on what the file shows.

Two scenarios

Scenario one, illustrative. A solo practitioner prepares amended returns for individuals. A client offers to pay a share of any refund that results. The amended return is a refund claim, which the definition covers, and the exceptions listed above do not obviously fit a new claim of this kind. The practitioner should decline the percentage and quote a fee set in advance. If the situation might fall within an exception, for example because the IRS has already given written notice of an examination, read the section's conditions and the timing before agreeing. For a CPA in public practice, the AICPA rule also bars preparing an amended return or refund claim for a contingent fee, and the Code gives as an example an amended return claiming a refund because a valid deduction was left off the original (ET 1.510.010.05).

Scenario two, illustrative. A firm engages a freelancer to review the work papers behind a set of returns and offers an extra payment for each file in which the reviewer finds no changes are needed. The pay now depends on the result of the review. Even if section 10.27 does not apply to this particular service, the freelancer should ask the firm about its own policy and the AICPA rule, and should consider whether a payment that rewards "no findings" creates pressure on judgement. The simpler fix is a fixed fee per file regardless of findings.

What to do

  • Before you sign, read each pay clause and ask one question: does any amount depend on what the file, the return or the IRS ends up showing?
  • If yes, propose a fixed fee set in advance for the same scope.
  • If the buyer insists, ask for the buyer's written position on which rule it relies on, and take that to your own adviser or the board that licenses you.
  • Keep the agreement and any emails on fee terms with your engagement records.
  • If you work outside the US, add your own regulator's fee rules to the check; they may be different.

Frequently asked questions

Is a per-file fee a contingent fee?

Not if the price per file is fixed in advance and paid whatever the file shows. It is the dependency on outcome that makes a fee contingent.

Can I charge an hourly fee that has a cap?

A cap on hours is not an outcome. The question is still whether the amount depends on how a position fares.

Does the rule stop me getting a bonus?

A bonus linked to the result of a return position can be contingent. A bonus linked to something else, such as delivery before an agreed date, does not turn on a position being sustained. State its trigger in writing.

Where does the AICPA rule apply?

It binds AICPA members in public practice. The text is at ET 1.510.001 in the Code, with tax examples at ET 1.510.010. Read it in the full Code and check which services it covers before you rely on this summary of the IRS rule alone.

Who decides whether an arrangement is contingent?

The regulation and the body that enforces it. This page is general information and not legal advice. For a specific arrangement, ask the board that licenses you or a professional adviser.

Where the official text is

Circular 230 section 10.27 is published on the eCFR. The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct is published by the AICPA; the contingent-fee section is ET 1.510.001. A full-text copy of the Code is linked below.

Sources

Last verified November 20, 2026. Sources checked by the editorial team; not yet reviewed by a named professional. General information, not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Related pages

Terms used on this page

Contingent fee

Join the CORAA CPA network waitlist

CORAA prepares audit files for US CPA firms. Network members are independent contractors who clear what the software flags, with evidence and a note, paid per file under a contractor agreement.

  • Files are offered to you; you accept or decline
  • No exclusivity: you can work for others
  • The firm reviews and signs; CORAA never does

* required