CORAA
Blog/Tax Compliance

F&O Turnover for Tax Audit: The 8th vs 10th Edition ICAI Method, Explained

The 2025 ICAI Guidance Note reinstated option premium into the F&O turnover formula — reversing what the 8th edition had removed for AY 2022-23 onward. Using the older formula today understates turnover, and can wrongly clear a client of a tax audit that's actually required.

CCORAA Team23 July 20265 min read

F&O turnover isn't the value of contracts traded — it's a specifically defined figure under ICAI's Guidance Note on Tax Audit under Section 44AB, and that definition changed between editions in a way that matters for anyone still working from an older reference.

The Current (10th Edition) Formula

For AY 2026-27 onward, per the 10th edition (Revised 2025) of the ICAI Guidance Note:

F&O turnover = sum of absolute favourable and unfavourable differences on squared-off trades (futures and options alike) + premium received on sale of options

Two components, added together, not netted against each other:

  1. The absolute P&L sum — every squared-off trade's profit or loss, taken as an absolute value and summed, so gains and losses both add to turnover rather than offsetting
  2. Option-sale premium received — added on top, for options specifically

Why the 8th vs 10th Edition Distinction Matters

The 8th edition of the Guidance Note (applicable from AY 2022-23) had removed the option-premium add-on that older editions carried — for several assessment years, turnover was computed on the absolute P&L sum alone, with premium not separately added.

The 10th edition (Revised 2025), applicable from AY 2026-27, reinstated the premium component — an edition-over-edition reversal, not a continuation of the 8th edition's simplified formula. Anyone computing F&O turnover today using the 8th-edition method — absolute P&L sum only, no premium add-on — is applying a superseded formula and will understate turnover for AY 2026-27 and later years.

Why Understating Turnover Is a Real Compliance Risk, Not Just an Arithmetic Slip

F&O turnover directly determines whether a Section 44AB tax audit is required in the first place, and which presumptive scheme thresholds apply. A trader whose turnover is understated by omitting the premium component can be wrongly concluded to fall below the tax audit threshold, when the correctly-computed (premium-inclusive) figure would actually require one. This isn't a rounding difference — for an active options trader, premium received on written options can be a substantial fraction of total turnover, large enough on its own to flip an audit-required conclusion.

The Anti-Double-Count Proviso

The formula carries an explicit safeguard: where a broker's own P&L statement has already netted the premium into the per-trade result (rather than reporting it separately), adding the premium again would double-count it. The correct approach checks whether the broker's reported P&L figure already reflects premium, and adds the premium separately only where it hasn't already been absorbed into that per-trade number.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should option premium be added to F&O turnover or not?

For AY 2026-27 onward (10th edition, Revised 2025), yes — option-sale premium received is added to the absolute P&L sum. This reverses the 8th edition's approach (AY 2022-23 onward), which had removed the premium add-on.

What happens if I use the 8th edition formula for a current-year tax audit assessment?

Turnover will be understated, because the option-premium component that the 10th edition reinstated won't be captured. This can incorrectly conclude that a tax audit isn't required when the properly-computed figure would trigger one.

Does the premium get added even if the broker's P&L already includes it?

No — that's exactly what the anti-double-count proviso addresses. Where the broker's reported P&L per trade has already netted the premium into the result, adding it again as a separate line item would double-count it. Check the broker's methodology before adding premium separately.

Is the turnover formula the same for futures and options?

The absolute-P&L-sum component applies to both futures and options alike. The premium add-on applies specifically to options — sale of options generates premium income that futures trading doesn't have an equivalent of.


CORAA's F&O Turnover Calculator applies the current 10th-edition formula — the absolute P&L sum plus option premium, with the anti-double-count check against a broker P&L that may have already netted it in — rather than the superseded 8th-edition method that's still circulating in older reference material.

Topics
F&O turnover tax auditICAI guidance note 10th editionoption premium turnoverfutures options turnover 44AB
Share

Statutory facts on this page are checked against their sources, and the page says where it relied on secondary reporting. How we verify · Report an error

← Back to all articles
Part of a topic hub
Statutory audit in India: Companies Act, standards and reports →
Every guide, template and free tool on this topic in one place, with FAQs.
Keep reading

More in tax compliance.

Built for India · DPDPA compliant

Ready to automate your audit work.

See how Coraa reduces audit engagement time by 60%, from ledger scrutiny to working papers, all from one Tally import.

Run one complete audit free