Clause 3(xx) asks whether a company that had unspent CSR money moved it to the right place, by the right date. Clause 3(xxi) asks, in the report on consolidated financial statements, whether any group company's own CARO report carried a qualification or adverse remark. Both clauses are about following a procedure, so the work is mostly dates, bank statements and a list.
Facts checked: 20 November 2026. We read secondary commentary on the clauses (the Taxmann clause 3(xx)–3(xxi) checklist and a Taxclue breakdown) and KPMG's CARO 2020 material. We could not open the notified Order text, so the clause wording below is paraphrased, not quoted, and the sample reporting is our own illustration. Read the Order and the current ICAI Guidance Note before you sign. For the wider clause list see the clause-by-clause guide, and for how to use the Note see ICAI's Guidance Note on CARO 2020.
Clause 3(xx): unspent CSR
Step zero: does Section 135 apply?
If Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 does not apply to the company, the commentary we read treats sub-clauses (a) and (b) as not applicable. Section 135 is triggered when, in the immediately preceding financial year, the company had any one of:
- net worth of ₹500 crore or more,
- turnover of ₹1,000 crore or more, or
- net profit of ₹5 crore or more.
Check the trigger first and write the conclusion in the file, even when the answer is "not applicable". A reviewer wants to see that you tested it, not that you assumed it.
Sub-clause (a): unspent amount, no ongoing project
If a CSR amount was left unspent and it does not relate to an ongoing project, the question is whether the company transferred it to a fund specified in Schedule VII within six months of the end of the financial year. This follows the second proviso to Section 135(5).
Sub-clause (b): unspent amount, ongoing project
If an amount was left unspent under Section 135(5) because of an ongoing project, the question is whether it was transferred to the special account that Section 135(6) requires. The company opens an Unspent CSR Account, and the transfer is due within 30 days of the end of the financial year.
The two limbs are easy to cross. The six-month Schedule VII fund route is for money not tied to an ongoing project. The 30-day Unspent CSR Account route is for ongoing projects. Keep them on separate lines in the working paper.
What to test
| Step | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Confirm the Section 135 trigger from the prior year's net worth, turnover and net profit | Prior-year audited financial statements |
| Recompute the obligation: 2% of average net profit of the three preceding financial years | CSR computation, board-approved CSR policy |
| Compare against actual CSR spend, split into ongoing and other projects | CSR ledger, project approvals, utilisation certificates |
| Trace each transfer: amount, date, receiving account or fund | Bank statements, challans, the CSR-2 filing |
| Count the days: 30 days for the Unspent CSR Account, six months for the Schedule VII fund | Working paper with the year-end date and the transfer date side by side |
| Check the board report disclosure agrees with the books | Board's report CSR annexure |
Where firms go wrong
- A project is labelled "ongoing" to avoid the six-month deadline, but it has no approved multi-year plan. Ask for the board approval and the timeline.
- The transfer is made, but a few days late. The clause is about compliance with the proviso, so a late transfer is a reportable matter even when the full amount was moved.
- The Unspent CSR Account is opened but the transfer is shown in a different bank account in the books. Match the account number on the bank statement to the one named in the CSR policy.
- CSR spend is counted that does not fall under Schedule VII. This affects the unspent figure, so it flows into clause (xx).
Illustrative reporting
These are our own drafts to show structure. Adapt them to the facts and to your firm's template.
No exception: "The Company has complied with the requirement to transfer unspent Corporate Social Responsibility amounts to the funds and special account required by Section 135 of the Act, within the periods specified."
Exception (late transfer): "In respect of ongoing projects, the Company transferred ₹[amount] of the unspent Corporate Social Responsibility amount to the Unspent CSR Account on [date], after the 30 days permitted by Section 135(6) of the Act."
Not applicable: "Section 135 of the Act is not applicable to the Company. Accordingly, reporting under clause 3(xx) of the Order is not applicable."
Clause 3(xxi): remarks in group-company CARO reports
This clause is different in kind. It does not apply when you report on a standalone company. It arises when you are the auditor of the consolidated financial statements.
The question is whether the auditors of the companies included in the consolidation reported any qualification or adverse remark in their own CARO reports. If so, your report lists the companies and the paragraph numbers of the CARO reports in which the remarks appear.
What to do
- List the group. Subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures in the consolidation.
- Ask which of them are subject to CARO. A foreign subsidiary, for example, has no CARO report. Record that reason, not a blank.
- Collect each CARO report from the component auditors, with the clause numbers.
- Pull out the qualifications and adverse remarks. A plain "yes" on a clause, such as a fixed-asset register that is maintained, is not a remark. A matter such as unpaid statutory dues or a loan default is.
- Prepare the table of company, CARO paragraph and nature of the remark for your report.
- Chase late reports early. A component auditor's report that arrives after your own timetable is the most common reason this clause is rushed.
Illustrative reporting
Remarks present: "Following are the qualifications or adverse remarks reported by the respective auditors in the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order reports of the companies included in the consolidated financial statements: [name of company, CIN, relevant clause, nature of remark]."
None: "There are no qualifications or adverse remarks by the respective auditors in the CARO reports of the companies included in the consolidated financial statements."
A control that helps
Ask every component auditor to send the CARO report with a one-line list of the clause numbers carrying a remark. It turns the consolidation of clause (xxi) from a read-through of every report into a check against a list.
Frequently asked questions
Does clause 3(xxi) apply to a standalone audit?
No. It is relevant only in the auditor's report on consolidated financial statements. For a standalone company, report that it is not applicable.
Is a late CSR transfer reportable if the money did reach the account?
Clause 3(xx) tests compliance with the provisions of Section 135, which carry the deadlines. A late transfer is a departure from them, so consider reporting it with the amount and date, as in the illustration above.
Do we report under clause 3(xx) if CSR spend exceeded the obligation?
If nothing was left unspent, the transfer question does not arise. Say so in the working paper, with the computation that shows it.
Which ICAI paragraph covers this?
We could not open the Guidance Note and quote no paragraph. Check the current edition's guidance on clauses 3(xx) and 3(xxi) before relying on our summary.
Related reading
Statutory facts on this page are checked against their sources, and the page says where it relied on secondary reporting. How we verify · Report an error