CORAA
University · Engagement quality

Working Paper Review Point Tracker.

Paste the review points raised on an engagement with who raised them and when each was cleared. Enter an as-of date and an overdue limit. The tool shows what is still open, how long it has waited and which reviewer has the most outstanding.

Review points

Leave Cleared on blank for points still open. Dates can be dd/mm/yyyy, dd-mm-yyyy or yyyy-mm-dd.

Set the overdue limit from your own file closure timetable. Check the current file assembly requirements in your standards.

Open points and ageing
Points raised6
Cleared2
Still open4
Open and overdue4
Oldest open point (days)2,236
Average days open2,223.0
Average days to clear7.0
ReviewerOpenOverdueCleared
Meera221
Arun221
PointWorking paperReviewerRaisedDays openStatus
RP-02D-12 DebtorsMeera2020-09-022,236Overdue
RP-03F-04 Fixed assetsArun2020-09-052,233Overdue
RP-05C-03 CashMeera2020-09-222,216Overdue
RP-06P-02 ProvisionsArun2020-10-012,207Overdue

Open review points hold up sign-off.

Review comments that sit open past the planned date delay the report and the archive of the file. A tracker puts every point, its reviewer and its age in one place. Clear the oldest first, and look at which working papers keep generating points, because that often shows where the preparer needs guidance.

Audit time estimatorAction taken report tracker

How the tracker works

Each line is one review point. A point with a cleared date is closed. A point without one is open and its age is counted from the raised date to your as-of date.

Open points older than the limit you set are marked overdue. Totals are shown for each reviewer.

The Excel file lists every point with its days open and a column for the preparer response.

Worked example — an old open point

A review point was raised on 2 September and is still open on 17 October. The limit is 7 days.

Inputs
Raised on02/09/2026
As-of date17/10/2026
Overdue after7 days
Output
Days open45
StatusOverdue
The point goes to the top of the open list because it has waited the longest.

Common mistakes

Clearing a point without evidence
Record where the answer is in the file before you fill the cleared date.
Mixing review points with to-do items
Keep one list per engagement so the counts are meaningful.
Ignoring repeat areas
Many points on one working paper usually need a conversation, not another comment.

Frequently asked questions

What columns are needed?+
A header row, then point number, working paper, review point, reviewer, raised on and cleared on.
What counts as overdue?+
Open for more days than the limit you enter.
Is my data uploaded?+
No. Everything runs in your browser.

Authoritative sources

ICAI — SA 220, Quality Management for an Audit of Financial Statements — Engagement team direction, supervision and review. Check the current text.
Always confirm against the latest version of the source. Regulations evolve and amendments are common.
Related calculators
Audit time estimator →Action taken report tracker →SQM 1 implementation checklist →
Share this tool
Last reviewed: 2026-10-17 · For informational purposes only — not professional advice.